Refinancing existing debt vs Additional facility

Refinancing existing debt vs taking an additional facility

Refinancing replaces an existing facility with a new one, often to secure better terms or release equity. Taking an additional facility leaves the existing arrangement untouched and adds new borrowing alongside it, usually against different or additional security.

Side by side

CriterionRefinancing existing debtAdditional facility
Effect on existing debtReplaced entirely by the new facilityRemains in place, unaffected
Security implicationsExisting charges released and replacedNew charges added, existing ones stay as they are
Typical triggerBetter rate available, term ending, or equity release neededAdditional funding need without disturbing current terms
ComplexityRequires settling and closing the old facilitySimpler, existing facility untouched
Cost considerationsMay involve early repayment charges on the old facilityNo impact on existing facility's terms or charges
Overall debt levelCan stay similar, or increase if extra funds are drawnIncreases, since it sits on top of existing debt

When refinancing is the right move

Refinancing makes sense when the existing facility no longer suits the business, whether because a better rate is now available, the term is coming to an end, or the business wants to release equity built up in an asset. It effectively resets the arrangement, and any early repayment charges on the old facility need to be weighed against the benefit of the new terms.

When an additional facility makes more sense

If the existing facility is on good terms and simply needs topping up, or the new need relates to a different asset or purpose entirely, adding a facility alongside the existing one avoids disturbing arrangements that are already working well. This is often quicker and cheaper than unwinding and replacing an existing facility unnecessarily.

Working out the total cost either way

The comparison should always include any early repayment or exit charges on the existing facility, the arrangement fees on the new one, and the interest rate difference over the likely remaining life of the debt. In many cases, particularly where an existing facility is only part way through its term, an additional facility alongside it turns out to be the cheaper and simpler route.

The short answer

Refinance where the existing facility's terms, rate or structure no longer suit the business; add a new facility alongside it where the current arrangement is working well and only a top up is needed.

Questions

Will refinancing always trigger an early repayment charge?

Not always, but many facilities include one, particularly if you are within a fixed rate period, so it is worth checking the original terms before deciding to refinance.

Can I take an additional facility if my existing lender holds a debenture over all assets?

It is possible but usually requires the existing lender's consent or a carve out for the new lender's security, so this needs checking early in the process.

Is refinancing worth it just to release a small amount of equity?

It depends on the cost of unwinding the existing facility versus the benefit gained, so it is worth comparing against simply adding a smaller, separate facility instead.

Not sure which route fits? Describe the requirement once and we will structure it and approach the providers whose criteria match. No upfront fees — charges are due only once funding is in place.

Start a funding request